HELOC vs. Home Equity Loan: Compare Your Options
Both products borrow against property equity and use the home as collateral. A home equity loan generally provides a lump sum; a HELOC permits draws against an available line during its borrowing period. If you already have a mortgage, the new payment is generally additional to the first mortgage. See the CFPB comparison.
How access and payments differ
A home equity loan may have a fixed or adjustable rate and its own payment schedule. A HELOC usually has an adjustable rate, so its payment can vary with the balance and rate; some plans offer fixed-rate conversion options. Some HELOCs permit interest-only draw-period payments, while others require principal or different minimums. At the end, the agreement may require amortizing payments or a lump-sum balance.
A lump sum can fit a known bill, but interest generally starts on the full loan amount. A line can make staged draws possible, subject to its minimums, fees and availability. Repaying a draw may replenish available credit during the draw period, but the lender may restrict access in certain circumstances. Ask how the specific plan works.
Example: same $50,000 and five-year horizon
Imagine needing $50,000 immediately and keeping the debt for at least five years. A hypothetical fixed home equity loan is repaid monthly over ten years at 9%, with a $500 opening fee. Alternatively, draw $50,000 at once on a HELOC at 8.5%, assumed unchanged, with a ten-year interest-only draw period, a $300 opening fee and a $50 annual fee for five years. Pay fees from separate cash. These are not offers, and neither example includes taxes, insurance or other fees.
- Home equity loan: about $633.38 monthly principal and interest. After 60 payments, about $38,002.73 has been paid, $30,512.00 remains, and interest paid is about $18,514.73. Including the opening fee gives $19,014.73 in interest and fees.
- HELOC: about $354.17 per month in interest only. After 60 payments, interest paid is $21,250 and the full $50,000 remains. With $550 in opening and annual fees, interest and fees are $21,800.
The lower HELOC payment in this example does not repay any principal. The fixed loan costs about $2,785 less in interest and stated fees over the five years, but requires larger payments and leaves a smaller balance. Neither result represents lifetime cost. The HELOC could become more or less expensive if its rate or draw schedule changes. The amortizing payment and balance use the formula in our methodology, without rounding until display.
Compare the terms that could change the result
Use the amount and timing you actually need. Include the cost of holding an unused line, any minimum draw and a possible early-closure charge. Test the post-draw payment and a higher HELOC rate; an agreement may instead require a balloon. If predictability is important, check the rate and payment terms of each actual offer rather than assuming every home equity loan is fixed.
Do not compare APRs alone: the CFPB cautions that a closed-end loan APR can include fees that a HELOC APR does not. Add actual fees separately and compare payments and remaining balances on the same date. Both products can lead to foreclosure if payments are not made.
Use the calculator to explore a simplified HELOC, then see how to compare fees and plan for repayment. Whether interest is deductible depends on the use of funds and other IRS requirements; do not assume a tax benefit.
Educational information only, not individualized financial, legal or tax advice. Check current terms with your lender and applicable rules with a qualified professional.