HELOCLedger

HELOC vs. Cash-Out Refinance: Compare the Whole Debt

A HELOC generally adds a credit line secured by your home while your existing mortgage remains in place. A cash-out refinance replaces that mortgage with a larger one; the difference provides cash after any amounts withheld at closing. Both put the home at risk if you cannot repay. The CFPB compares these alternatives and notes that either can be more or less expensive depending on its terms.

A five-year comparison with the same cash

Suppose $400,000 remains on a fixed-rate first mortgage, with 30 years left at 4%, and you want $50,000 of cash. Compare two hypothetical ways to receive that same $50,000. These rates and fees are examples, not offers. For simplicity, pay all fees from separate savings rather than financing or deducting them from the cash received.

Assume the HELOC charges $1,500 to open and $75 each year for five full years, or $1,875 in total fees. Assume the refinance charges $4,000 at closing and no later fees. There are no other fees, extra payments, changes in rate, taxes, insurance or tax benefits. These assumptions are deliberately simple; actual offers can differ.

Payments, interest and debt remaining

After 60 monthly payments, keeping the first mortgage and adding the HELOC results in approximately $135,829.67 in principal-and-interest payments, with $411,790.05 still owed across both balances. Of the payments, $97,619.72 is interest. Adding the assumed fees gives $99,494.72 in five-year interest and fees.

The refinance results in approximately $179,631.67 in principal-and-interest payments, with $423,592.15 still owed. Interest is $153,223.83; with the $4,000 fee, five-year interest and fees are $157,223.83. For these particular assumptions, the HELOC path has about $57,729 less interest and fees over five years. It also leaves a different balance, so the comparison does not establish the eventual lifetime cost.

To reproduce the numbers, calculate each fixed loan's monthly payment using its starting balance, annual rate divided by 12 and 360 monthly payments. Compute the balance after payment 60, then use payments minus principal repaid to find interest. For the HELOC, $50,000 × 8.5% ÷ 12 is $354.17 monthly interest; the full $50,000 remains owed after five years. Use unrounded monthly values until the final step. See the payment formula.

Change the terms and the result can reverse

Keep the same balances, HELOC rate, fees and schedules, but suppose the existing mortgage is at 7% and a fixed refinance is available at 4%, both over 30 years. Five-year interest and fees become about $159,323.96 for the first mortgage plus HELOC, versus $89,915.94 for the refinance. Balances after five years are about $426,526.36 and $407,013.81 respectively. This is a sensitivity illustration, not a prediction that such a refinance will be offered.

A variable HELOC rate could rise or fall, and the first scenario stops during the draw period, before the repayment transition or any balloon. More or fewer draws, fees financed into the loan, a different sale date, prepayment, tax treatment and the time value of money can change the comparison. A lower first payment alone does not settle the question.

Apply the comparison to offers

Ask for the cash actually received, the existing loan payoff, new rates and payment schedules, and all opening, annual and early-closure charges. Compare both paths through the same sale, refinance or payoff date, including both outstanding balances and fees on each path. Consider a higher HELOC rate and the payment after draw. IRS Publication 936 explains conditions for the home mortgage interest deduction; do not assume either option has a tax benefit.

For the separate line, use the HELOC calculator as a constant-rate illustration. It does not model the first mortgage, fees or a changing rate. See also HELOC closing costs and draw and repayment periods.

Educational information only, not individualized financial, legal or tax advice. Check current terms with your lender and applicable rules with a qualified professional.